Pet Foods Settlement Claim a Refund for Recalled Pet Food 2024

Pet Foods

The Midwestern Pet Foods recalls occurred in late 2020 and early 2021 after some of their pet food products were found to be contaminated with unsafe levels of aflatoxin or salmonella. This resulted in a class action lawsuit and a settlement from which owners affected by the recalls could claim compensation. This article details the recalls, the subsequent class action and settlement through the official claims website

The 2020-2021 Pet Food Recalls

In late 2020 and early 2021, Midwestern Pet Foods issued several voluntary recalls after some of their dog and cat food products tested positive for unsafe levels of aflatoxin or salmonella during internal testing. Aflatoxin is a toxin produced by the mould Aspergillus flavus that can cause illness or death in pets if consumed in high amounts. Salmonella is a type of bacteria that can sicken animals and spread to their owners.

The first recall was issued on December 30, 2020, and involved Sportmix pet food products. This was followed by more Sportmix product recalls on January 11, 2021, and additional Midwestern Pet Foods brand products placed on March 26, 2021. Around 100 dry pet food products under the Pro Pac, Splash, Sportstrail, Sportmix and Nunn Better brands were recalled across all 50 states due to contamination issues. Owners who had purchased any of the recalled products were advised to stop feeding them to their pets immediately.

The Class Action Lawsuit

After the recalls, a class action lawsuit was filed against Midwestern Pet Foods Inc. and Nunn Milling Co., the manufacturers of the contaminated pet foods. The lawsuit alleged that the companies had failed to adequately test for toxins in their products, misleadingly marketed pet foods that could pose health risks and that pet illnesses and deaths resulted from consuming the recalled pet foods.

Midwestern Pet Foods denied the allegations but agreed to a $13.5 million settlement in 2022 to resolve the class action without going to trial. As part of the settlement, a settlement website was established at, where owners affected by the recalls could register to claim cash compensation. Claims were accepted for veterinary costs from pet illnesses linked to recalled foods and partial refunds for unopened bags of recalled products still in owners’ possession.

Filing a Claim through

The website provided class members instructions on filing claims, relevant documents like claim forms and court notices, and answers to frequently asked questions. Owners had until August 3, 2023, to file claims for reimbursement.

Owners had to fill out an online or paper claim form to file a claim. For pet injury claims, vet records or a statement linking the illness to recalled food was required. Partial refund claims needed proof of purchase for unopened recalled products. The settlement administrator then reviewed claims, and payment amounts were determined based on the number and types of valid claims received, with payouts potentially being reduced if too many claims were submitted.

Payments and Deadlines

As of the fall of 2023, the settlement website indicated that claim forms had been processed and approved payments were being issued. Unfortunately, owners who missed the August 2023 claim deadline would not be eligible for reimbursement.

The website also provided status updates on essential settlement dates, like the objection deadline of August 3, 2023, and the final approval hearing held on August 21, 2023, where the presiding judge granted final settlement approval. Owners could continue checking for future announcements on payment disbursements as the remaining approved claims are completed.

Eligibility for Filing Claims

Several requirements had to be met to be eligible to file a claim through the website. Claimants needed to be legal residents of the United States who had purchased one or more of the recalled Midwestern Pet Foods or Nunn Milling Co. products for their pets. Products are qualified if purchased between July 1, 2020, and May 13, 2022. Pet owners and businesses like pet stores or veterinary clinics accepted claims.

Types of Claims Accepted

The settlement allowed for two main types of claims – pet injury claims and consumer food purchase claims. Pet injury claims reimbursed eligible veterinary expenses from pets who became ill or died after consuming recalled food. Consumer claims gave partial refunds for unopened bags of recalled products returned to retailers or surrendered to claims administrators. Proof of purchase was required for consumer claims to determine refund amounts.

Claim Processing and Payments

Once submitted, claims went through a review and validation process managed by the appointed settlement administrator. This involved verifying eligibility requirements were met, examining supporting documentation, and determining payment amounts based on claim details and total number of claims received. Validated claims received an assigned payment amount, with checks issued once the settlement received final approval from the judge.

Objecting to the Settlement

As with any class action settlement, members had the right to object if they disagreed with certain aspects. Those wishing to object had until August 3, 2023, to submit their reasons directly to the court. Objections needed to specify what was being opposed to, along with personal details and interest in the case. However, objecting did not permit opting out of the settlement – one still had to decide whether to participate or exclude themselves entirely.

Nutritional Deficiencies in Recalled Pet Foods

Several Midwestern Pet Foods and Nunn Milling Co. products recalled in late 2020 and early 2021 were found to have nutritional deficiencies in addition to unsafe toxin and bacterial contaminations. Laboratory testing done by authorities as part of the recall investigation revealed that some dry dog and cat food products lacked adequate levels of proteins, fats, vitamins and minerals required to maintain pets’ health.

This meant animals consuming these deficient diets long-term could have experienced symptoms such as weight loss, lethargy, and skin and coat issues. While nutrition was not the direct cause of illnesses linked to the contaminated foods, the lack of essential nutrients likely weakened the immunity of pets who later contracted infections from Salmonella or were poisoned by high Aflatoxin levels. In the future, the settlement helped raise awareness for pet owners to scrutinize product labels and ingredients more closely to ensure their furry companions receive balanced nutrition from their daily food.

Requesting Exclusion

As an alternative to objecting or filing a claim through the settlement, owners could request exclusion by the August 3 deadline. This allowed “opting-out” to pursue individual litigation and excluded participation in the class and any awarded benefits. Exclusion requests required a signed letter with personal details and a statement requesting exclusion sent directly to the administrator.

Future Updates

Even after the final approval in August 2023, remained active in providing ongoing public announcements about settlement status. This included new deadlines, information regarding outstanding or appealed claims, and notification when all settlement funds were fully distributed. The website served as the official source for all settlement-related public information.


In summary, the Midwestern Pet Foods recalls of 2020-2021 led to a class action settlement that compensated affected pet owners through a claims process at By filing claims by the deadline, eligible owners could receive reimbursements for related veterinary costs or refunds on unopened recalled products. The website continues providing status updates for those still awaiting payments or with additional questions about the settlement.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *